Tuesday, December 30, 2008

The End of a Tumultuous Year

The year's been long, with ups and downs, but what a good year it has been. Looking back, I must say that I have learnt a lot about the markets and investing, and how to handle emotions. Let's take a quick flashback on the year that is just about to pass.




2008 ushered in one of the worst performances of the markets to date. The markets were hit by bad news one after another. We started off with Bear Stearns, the quickfire sale to JP Morgan and the U.S government's involvement in it. The 4th largest bank, a century old bank, brought to its knees, once worth $180/share, and the idea of selling it at $2/share was mooted at one point of time.




Now, nobody's gonna forget the mortgage lenders as well, Fannie and Freddie. There used to be an air of invincibility about the 2 lenders, that government support would render them infallible. And then, the markets actually started to doubt the sustainability of the 2 lenders, and the selldown ensued.




Lehmann Brothers was the next victim to have its scalp claimed. Another century old bank, suffering a run, and it went down within a short period. This is bad, the market claimed, and we saw fresh new lows being set and risk aversion at its highest.




Then, around the same period of time, the famous bull of Merrill Lynch, the world's largest brokerage, was sold to Bank of America. Morgan Stanley and Goldman were "converted" to commercial banks for purpose of raising of equity, and this marked the demise of the investment banking business model that had been the success story of the decade where all excesses of the financial world had gathered.


Many high profile corporations were victims of the crisis. Bill Miller, proud record holder of beating the S&P for 15 straight years, has been brought down to his knees, now currently amongst the top 3 for the worst performing fund in 1-yr,3-yr and 5-yr. Washington Mutual, the nice resident bank, with the highly-rated WaMu business model, also went kaput. Many scandals plagued the financial world as well, we had the Madoff scandal, and closer to home, the controversial Lehmann Minibonds saga.


So many incidents, so much turmoil. Consider ourselves lucky to have the chance to look back, years from now, upon this year where presidential elections and terrorist attacks were not the ones that screamed across headlines, but rather, a whole slew of events that threatened to cripple the grand 'ol America.


Even if some of us might emerge from this crisis bruised financially, however, whatever doesn't kill us only makes us stronger. The crisis would almost definitely make us mentally stronger, and emerge as a far better investor by training us to handle our emotions better.


On a personal level, my investing journey has started from the time when the STI was around 3400+ to today's 1700+. That's a close to 50% drop, a very scary period indeed for a novice investor. Nonetheless, coupled with dividends, some nimbleness, a little trading plus lots of luck, I have managed to stay pretty decent. A quick look at my holdings, and the lessons I have learnt from my trading so far.




Let's look back at some lessons that I have learnt.
1) Do nothing when I've nothing to do.
My first foray into the markets was the STI ETF. I lost about $100 on it. The purchase was bought on impulse, I did not think about whether the ETF would be a better alternative to the other companies trading on the SGX at that point of time. I decided to cash out at about the same price that I bought it at, but minus the trading fees.
2) Really understand the businesses that you own, and if u're unsure, stay clear.
I didn't really learn this lesson the hard way, though I looked back and realised that things could have been much grim-mer. I did my research on both companies, but it was very insufficient and I did not have a clear mind as to how the company's operations would be hit and it's competitive strengths. I bought NOL and Sembmar and sold them at around 15% and <10%>
3) Don't take profits for the sake of taking them.
I took profits for NOL and Sembmar because I felt the market's were starting to become a bit optimistic. Pretty silly looking back, because I did not exactly determine, through calculations, why the market was optimistic. It brought me some cash in, and the decision "paid off", but problem is that this is definitely not a method I would be able to employ successfully for my entire investing journey. Pure luck I would say.
I have learnt to not take profits and hold on to them, and even if the profits turn into losses, it's perfectly fine. Do the homework, be sure to handle the price levels and reasons behind them, and we're probably on the way.
4) Build in expectations to ur calculations, and have a handle on why the prices are reflected at this particular level.
I did this for some of the property companies that I held. I incorporated the mark-to-market writedowns into the assets valuations, and found that some of the companies were trading at reasonable levels. It is NOT OUR JOB to predict how much write-downs there will be, but rather, to find out if the market is pricing in earning drops at reasonable levels. If you think so, pick them up. E.g. the markets priced in about 75% write-down in assets, but do note that Kepland's assets are backed by 25% of cash, and you can;t really write down cash can you? Thus I picked them up. Even if prices were to become even more depressed, I am comfortable with a 75% write-down level for Kepland.
5) Do your homework and have confidence in yourself.
I must admit that I have done some homework but still felt a dearth of confidence, which resulted in me previously taking profits. I have since ceased to do so a few months ago. Do your homework, estimate some downside risks. Try not to use relative valuations from previous crises, I believe, because companies that have survived the crises are probably more resilient and valuations will be different. Refer to operational performance instead.
Since then, I have still done a little trading, but very very minimal, and the last done was a few months ago for Parkway where I was "forced" to sell my shares as the markets were being overly optimistic, I figured, pricing in a 10% growth over the next few years when obviously the Group had been hit in the previous few crises( I took a look at the reports during those times). I booked some pretty decent profits of around 40+% before I bought it back at a lower price.
Shall probably talk soon about my individual holdings, the size of my portfolio, and other lessons I have learnt so far, other than the abovementioned 5.
Ciao 2008. Let's usher in the New Year.

3 comments:

Financial Journalist said...

In 2008 I had warned many people not to touch stocks. My advice is same for 2009.

patrickho said...

Hi BL,
I guess everybody has their own preferred mode of investing. I;m glad to hear that you're probably very versatile and understand all asset classes and alternative investments very well. As for myself, I choose to stick to what I;m familiar with, which is investing in companies that I can understand with a certain degree.

patrick

Anonymous said...

Hello Patrick!

I've been passionately doing a bit of value investing for a while now and since Feb 2009, I've built a site around this theme and would like to exchange links with like-minded individuals like yourself.

If you like my suggestion, do let me know if you're comfortable having me to link to your site at:

http://www.ValueInvestingAtSg.com/value-investing-blogs/

while you link my main site from your blogroll?


Thanks.
Be Blessed & Good Investing!